Startup
Start Your Business
Private Limited Registration
Public Company Registration
OPC Pvt Ltd Registration
LLP Firm Registration
Section 8 Company Registration
Nidhi Company Registration
Insurance Company Registration
NBFC Company Registration
Producer Company Registration
Foreign Subsidiary Registration
Foreign Branch Office
Foreign Liaison Office
Foreign Project Office
Overseas Company Registration
Proprietorship Firm Registration
Partnership Firm Registration
Grow Your Business
GST Registration
MSME Registration(UDYAM)
Shop & Establishment Registration
Startup India Registration
ESI/PF Registration
IEC Code (Import Export)
Startup Consultation
Appoint Virtual CFO
Angel Funding/ VCs
Virtual Office Service
Due Diligence of Company
Business Development
Protect Your Business
Trademark Registration
Trademark Objection
Trademark Hearing
Trademark Opposition
Trademark Infringement
Trademark Renewal
Trademark Assignment
Trademark Withdrawal
Trademark Monitoring
Logo Design Service
Copyright Registration
Patent Registration
Exit Your Business
Close Company
Fast Track
Close LLP
Close Firm
GST Cancellation
Compliances
Change Services
Change Company Name
Change LLP Name
Change Company Object
Change LLP Object
Increase Authorised Capital
Increase Paid-up Capital
Increase LLP Capital
Transfer of Shares
Alteration in MoA & AoA
Resignation of Auditor
Appointment of Director
Resignation of Director
Change in Designation of Director
Shifting Registered Office of Company
Shifting Registered Office of LLP
Dormant Status of Company
Mandatory Compliances
Appoinment of Auditor
Annual Filings of Company
Annual Filings of LLP
Annual DIN/DPIN KYC
Annual Return of Deposits
Half Yearly MSME Return
Statutory Registers & Minutes
XBRL Filing of Companies
eStamping of Share Certificates
Dematerialisation of Shares
RBI FEMA Compliance
GST Returns Filing
ESI-EPF Returns Filing
TDS Returns Filing
Change in Structure
Proprietorship to OPC
OPC to Private Limited
Private Limited to OPC
LLP to Private Limited
Private Limited to LLP
Partnership Firm to LLP
Private Limited to Public Company
Public Company to Private Limited
Trust/Society to Section 8 Company
Existing Company to Section 8
Existing Section 8 to Company
Services
Accounting & Book Keeping
GST Compliance
Valuation Services
Corporate Litigation
Company Law Advisory
Services For Banks
Drafting & Vetting Services
Business Setup Advisory
Startups Funding
Business Loans
Get in Touch
Govt Liaisoning
Retainership Services
NBFC
NBFC Company Registration
NBFC Micro-Finance Registration
NBFC P2P Lending Registration
NBFC Core Investment Company
NBFC ROC Compliance
NBFC RBI Compliance
NBFC License Restoration
NBFC Business Plan
NBFC Acquisition
NBFC Consultancy
NBFC Compliance Calendar
NBFC Independent Director
ISO
ISO 9001:2015
Most Demanded
ISO 14001:2015
ISO 13485:2016
OHSAS 18001:2007
HACCP Certification
CE Marking
GMP Certification
CMMI Level 3 Certification
ISO 22000:2005
ISO 27001:2013
FSSAI
FSSAI Registration
FSSAI State License
FSSAI Central License
FSSAI Registration Renewal
FSSAI License Renewal
FSSAI Returns Filing
FSSAI Compliances
FSSAI Consultancy
ITR
Salaried Person
TDS Refund
Firms/LLPs
Companies
NGOs
Income Tax Notice
Income Tax Planning
Income Tax Litigation
Income Tax Computation
Charity
Section 8 Company
Recommended
Trust Registration
Society Registration
80G & 12A Registration
FCRA Registration
NITI Ayog Registration
CSR-1 Registration
CSR 2 Report
CSR Services
NGO Consultancy
NGO Handholding
Govt Grants Support
Partnership
Angel Investors
Venture Capitalists
Co-Working Spaces
Banks and NBFCs
Incubation Centres
Government Wings
Institutional Bodies
Software Companies
CA/CS/CMA/Lawyers
Press & Media Houses
Overseas Ventures
Other Startup Enablers
Contact Us
Home
Are you a Director in a startup? Here's a roundup of recent cases affixing liabilities on Directors
Are you a Director in a startup? Here's a roundup of recent cases affixing liabilities on Directors
Volume
1
Rate
1
Pitch
1
Are you a Director in a startup? Here's a roundup of recent cases affixing liabilities on Directors . The recent prosecution of Chanda Kochhar, the CEO and Managing Director of ICICI Bank in the fraud loan case has once again brought the spotlight to the extent of liability of directors in a company. With myriad laws affixing responsibilities on Directors, such as the Companies Act, Foreign Exchange Management Act, the Negotiable Instruments Act and notifications issued under the same, it can be challenging keeping up with multiple compliances. In this post, Compliance Calendar simplifies the concept around directors’ liabilities in India for offenses committed by the company. Directors’ liabilities under FEMA Under Section 13 of the Foreign Exchange Management Act, any person, including a director can be held liable for penalty for the contravention of various provisions, notifications and orders issued under the Act. This includes a monetary penalty of up to three times the sum involved in the contravention (where amount is quantifiable) and up to two lac rupees (where the amount is not quantifiable). It may also entail an accumulated penalty of 5000 per day till the contravention continues. Vicarious liability of Directors under FEMA Section 42(1) of FEMA imposes vicarious liability on functionaries of the company who are responsible for the conduct of affairs of the company at the time of contravention. However, if the contravention took place without the Director’s knowledge or that he exercised all due diligence to prevent such contravention. The burden of proof is initially on the complainant to convince the court that the director was in-charge of day to day affairs. After this legal process, a director may be able to acquit himself by proving that either the act was beyond his scope of responsibility, or necessary safeguards were in place. Liability under Foreign Exchange laws is based on the role played in the company and not the designation In a recent case, the Supreme Court has held that the for proceeding against a Director of a company for contravention of provisions of FERA, 1973, the necessary ingredient for proceeding shall be that at the time offense was committed, the Director was in charge of and was responsible to the company for the conduct of the business of the company. The liability to be proceeded with for offense under Section 68 of FERA, 1973 depends on the role one plays in the affairs of the company and not on mere designation or status. (Shailendra Swarup vs. The Deputy Director, Enforcement Directorate) Directors liability under Negotiable Instruments Act To ensure credibility and efficiency in banking transactions, the sections 138 and 141 of the Negotiable Instruments provide for criminal liability of officers in charge of the company. Merely mentioning the title of director without substantially proving their role is an abuse of law Implicating directors blindly without the prosecution clearly demonstrating the actual role played by them is an abuse of legal principles. It was held that the impeaching of directors without reference to their role in relation to a transaction, or to the issuance or dishonor of a cheque by the company, requires to be discouraged, since it amounts to abuse of the salutary process of criminal law. (Sashi Kumar NagarJi & Ors. V. M/S Magnifico Minerals Pvt. Ltd & Org.) The Kerala High Court recently held that when it is found that the company has not committed the offense, and is acquitted, its directors, including the person signing the cheque as the Managing Director are also not liable to be convicted under Section 138 (Dishonor of Cheque). ( Afsal Hussain v. K.S. Muhammed Ismail & Anr.) Liability of Chairpersons or Heads of large conglomerates In a verdict delivered by the Delhi High Court in 2023 (Yashovardhan Birla vs Cecil Webber Engineering Ltd & Org.), the argument of the independent and non-executive Director, who was not managing the day-to-day affairs of the accused company and was not a signatory to the dishonored cheque issued by the company was accepted by the court in exonerating him. In the same case, it was also held that merely the mention of the name of a director on the letterhead as being the Head of the Group, does not ipso fact or ipso sure make him in-charge of and responsible for the affairs and business of the company at the time the offense was committed. Non-involvement in daily affairs by heads of large conglomerates and the onus on experts so appointed In the same case as above that discussed the liability of heads of large business conglomerates, it was stated that they are not involved in daily operations or the micro-management which is required to be done by the executive directors and officers of the company. In many companies, non-executive Directors are present on the Board of the Companies for their expert independent advice or oversight of the functioning of the company. A Chairperson or head may preside over the general meetings or of the functioning of the company and guide its business policies, and it need not interfere in the day-to-day affairs of the company. Thus, unless sufficient nexus is proven between the contravention and the involvement of the Chairperson, it is difficult to sustain a case against them. However, each case is judged on its own peculiar facts and circumstances. Directors responsibilities for statutory dues like taxation, PF Usually, for lack of clear statutory precedents, no liability is affixed on directors for non-payment of statutory dues such as taxation, employees provident fund contributions etc. However, in certain scenarios, the tax dues of a company can also be recovered from the Directors if it is shown that they were responsible for the affairs of the company and were responsible for non-compliance with provisions relating to Government dues. Moreover, with the enactment of anti-avoidance principles in taxation laws, a director must remain vigilant about statutory compliances. In several cases, the courts may apply the concept of “lifting of the corporate veil”, by which, the personnel operating the company may become personally responsible. (Prakash B. Kamat vs. Principal Commissioner of Income Tax) Under section 89 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017, the Directors of a Private Company where any tax, interest, or penalty cannot be recovered can be held jointly and severally liable. However, a director may be able to defend himself by proving that the non-recovery cannot be attributed to any gross neglect, misfeasance or breach of duty on his part in relation to the affairs of the company. Personal liability of directors When a director signs a document, or concludes an agreement in his personal capacity, even though on behalf of the company, he may be held to be personally liable. This was decided in the case Naresh Kumar Gupta v. Satya Pal & Org., CM (M) 66/2022, where the director had appended his signature to each of the settlement deeds twice, once in his personal capacity and once as the authorized signatory/ director of the Company. Thus, the director was not absolved from liability even after the Company was declared insolvent and resolution proceedings were commenced. The court held that possession and recovery of damages/mesne profits in respect of the property was executable against the director. Criminal liability under other Acts The above provisions that absolve directors from liability in corporate laws may be inapplicable when it comes to other protective laws, such as the Consumer Protection Act, the Drugs and Cosmetics Act etc. In a recent case that involved adulteration in a syrup made for pediatric use, the argument that the director was not involved in day to day affairs of the company failed. An offense by the company involving a public health hazard would be treated differently and more strictly by courts, including personal culpability of directors. (Rajnikant Gulabdas Patel Vs. State of Maharashtra) Thus, liability for non-compliance with corporate laws in India may attract personal liability on directors. It is also advisable to keep abreast of regulatory requirements specified under various laws applicable on your company as well as implementing robust corporate governance practices. In addition, Directors and Officers (D&O) insurance must be considered to provide financial protection to directors in case they are personally sued for alleged wrongful acts in their capacity as directors. It's crucial for directors to stay informed about the legal and regulatory framework governing their roles and responsibilities to avoid the risks associated with non-compliance. Connect with our experts at Compliance Calendar for professional legal advice on compliance matters. For latest news and advisory on compliances for startups, entrepreneurs and directors, follow our posts that underscore important regulations for navigating the legal landscape in India.
Share this article:
Search more articles:
You may also like
Laws on Appointment, Resignation and Removal of Statutory Auditors
Fast Track Exit (FTE) Closure of LLPs: Meaning, Conditions, Procedures and FAQs
Fast Track Exit (FTE) Closure of Companies: Meaning, Conditions, Procedures and FAQs
Change of Management in Companies – Appointment and Resignation of Director
Importance of Good Drafting And Vetting Services in Legal Agreements/ Documents
Procedural Aspects of Compounding of Offences Under the Companies Act, 2013
Can a Newly Incorporated Company be Converted into LLP
Which Company Cannot be Converted into LLP
Impact of GST on Food Delivery Startups Swiggy, Zomato, and many more
What is the Difference Between Tax Audit and Statutory Audit of a Company
What is Debt Funding and methods available for Businesses in India
Ways for Effective Implementation of POSH Act in India
How to Protect Trade Secrets of Your Business
Rights of Minority Shareholders - Safeguarding Minority Interests in Business
Process of FDI Approval for Investment in India from countries sharing land borders with India
How does Non-stamping of an Agreement & Share Certificates affect your business's legal rights
Start Your Business
Private Limited Registration
Public Company Registration
OPC Pvt Ltd Registration
LLP Firm Registration
Section 8 Company Registration
Nidhi Company Registration
Insurance Company Registration
NBFC Company Registration
Producer Company Registration
Foreign Subsidiary Registration
Foreign Branch Office
Foreign Liaison Office
Foreign Project Office
Overseas Company Registration
Proprietorship Firm Registration
Partnership Firm Registration
Grow Your Business
GST Registration
MSME Registration(UDYAM)
Shop & Establishment Registration
Startup India Registration
ESI/PF Registration
IEC Code (Import Export)
Startup Consultation
Appoint Virtual CFO
Angel Funding/ VCs
Virtual Office Service
Due Diligence of Company
Business Development
Protect Your Business
Trademark Registration
Trademark Objection
Trademark Hearing
Trademark Opposition
Trademark Infringement
Trademark Renewal
Trademark Assignment
Trademark Withdrawal
Trademark Monitoring
Logo Design Service
Copyright Registration
Patent Registration
Exit Your Business
Close Company
Fast Track
Close LLP
Close Firm
GST Cancellation
Change Services
Change Company Name
Change LLP Name
Change Company Object
Change LLP Object
Increase Authorised Capital
Increase Paid-up Capital
Increase LLP Capital
Transfer of Shares
Alteration in MoA & AoA
Resignation of Auditor
Appointment of Director
Resignation of Director
Change in Designation of Director
Shifting Registered Office of Company
Shifting Registered Office of LLP
Dormant Status of Company
Mandatory Compliances
Appoinment of Auditor
Annual Filings of Company
Annual Filings of LLP
Annual DIN/DPIN KYC
Annual Return of Deposits
Half Yearly MSME Return
Statutory Registers & Minutes
XBRL Filing of Companies
eStamping of Share Certificates
Dematerialisation of Shares
RBI FEMA Compliance
GST Returns Filing
ESI-EPF Returns Filing
TDS Returns Filing
Change in Structure
Proprietorship to OPC
OPC to Private Limited
Private Limited to OPC
LLP to Private Limited
Private Limited to LLP
Partnership Firm to LLP
Private Limited to Public Company
Public Company to Private Limited
Trust/Society to Section 8 Company
Existing Company to Section 8
Existing Section 8 to Company
Services
Accounting & Book Keeping
GST Compliance
Valuation Services
Corporate Litigation
Company Law Advisory
Services For Banks
Drafting & Vetting Services
Startups Funding
Business Loans
Get in Touch
NBFC
NBFC Company Registration
NBFC Micro-Finance Registration
NBFC P2P Lending Registration
NBFC Core Investment Company
NBFC ROC Compliance
NBFC RBI Compliance
NBFC License Restoration
NBFC Business Plan
NBFC Acquisition
NBFC Consultancy
NBFC Compliance Calendar
NBFC Independent Director
ISO
ISO 9001:2015
ISO 14001:2015
ISO 13485:2016
OHSAS 18001:2007
HACCP Certification
CE Marking
GMP Certification
CMMI Level 3 Certification
ISO 22000:2005
ISO 27001:2013
FSSAI
FSSAI Registration
FSSAI State License
FSSAI Central License
FSSAI Registration Renewal
FSSAI License Renewal
FSSAI Returns Filing
FSSAI Compliances
FSSAI Consultancy
ITR
Salaried Person
Firms/LLPs
Companies
NGOs
Income Tax Notice
Income Tax Planning
Income Tax Litigation
Charity
Section 8 Company
Trust Registration
Society Registration
80G & 12A Registration
FCRA Registration
NITI Ayog Registration
CSR-1 Registration
CSR 2 Report
CSR Services
NGO Consultancy
NGO Handholding
Govt Grants Support
Partnership
Angel Investors
Venture Capitalists
Co-Working Spaces
Banks and NBFCs
Incubation Centres
Government Wings
Institutional Bodies
Software Companies
CA/CS/CMA/Lawyers
Press & Media Houses
Overseas Ventures
Other Startup Enablers
Contact Us