Startup
Start Your Business
Private Limited Registration
Public Company Registration
OPC Pvt Ltd Registration
LLP Firm Registration
Section 8 Company Registration
Nidhi Company Registration
Insurance Company Registration
NBFC Company Registration
Producer Company Registration
Foreign Subsidiary Registration
Foreign Branch Office
Foreign Liaison Office
Foreign Project Office
Overseas Company Registration
Proprietorship Firm Registration
Partnership Firm Registration
Grow Your Business
GST Registration
MSME Registration(UDYAM)
Shop & Establishment Registration
Startup India Registration
ESI/PF Registration
IEC Code (Import Export)
Startup Consultation
Appoint Virtual CFO
Angel Funding/ VCs
Virtual Office Service
Due Diligence of Company
Business Development
Protect Your Business
Trademark Registration
Trademark Objection
Trademark Hearing
Trademark Opposition
Trademark Infringement
Trademark Renewal
Trademark Assignment
Trademark Withdrawal
Trademark Monitoring
Logo Design Service
Copyright Registration
Patent Registration
Exit Your Business
Close Company
Fast Track
Close LLP
Close Firm
GST Cancellation
Compliances
Change Services
Change Company Name
Change LLP Name
Change Company Object
Change LLP Object
Increase Authorised Capital
Increase Paid-up Capital
Increase LLP Capital
Transfer of Shares
Alteration in MoA & AoA
Resignation of Auditor
Appointment of Director
Resignation of Director
Change in Designation of Director
Shifting Registered Office of Company
Shifting Registered Office of LLP
Dormant Status of Company
Mandatory Compliances
Appoinment of Auditor
Annual Filings of Company
Annual Filings of LLP
Annual DIN/DPIN KYC
Annual Return of Deposits
Half Yearly MSME Return
Statutory Registers & Minutes
XBRL Filing of Companies
eStamping of Share Certificates
Dematerialisation of Shares
RBI FEMA Compliance
GST Returns Filing
ESI-EPF Returns Filing
TDS Returns Filing
Change in Structure
Proprietorship to OPC
OPC to Private Limited
Private Limited to OPC
LLP to Private Limited
Private Limited to LLP
Partnership Firm to LLP
Private Limited to Public Company
Public Company to Private Limited
Trust/Society to Section 8 Company
Existing Company to Section 8
Existing Section 8 to Company
Services
Accounting & Book Keeping
GST Compliance
Valuation Services
Corporate Litigation
Company Law Advisory
Services For Banks
Drafting & Vetting Services
Business Setup Advisory
Startups Funding
Business Loans
Get in Touch
Govt Liaisoning
Retainership Services
NBFC
NBFC Company Registration
NBFC Micro-Finance Registration
NBFC P2P Lending Registration
NBFC Core Investment Company
NBFC ROC Compliance
NBFC RBI Compliance
NBFC License Restoration
NBFC Business Plan
NBFC Acquisition
NBFC Consultancy
NBFC Compliance Calendar
NBFC Independent Director
ISO
ISO 9001:2015
Most Demanded
ISO 14001:2015
ISO 13485:2016
OHSAS 18001:2007
HACCP Certification
CE Marking
GMP Certification
CMMI Level 3 Certification
ISO 22000:2005
ISO 27001:2013
FSSAI
FSSAI Registration
FSSAI State License
FSSAI Central License
FSSAI Registration Renewal
FSSAI License Renewal
FSSAI Returns Filing
FSSAI Compliances
FSSAI Consultancy
ITR
Salaried Person
TDS Refund
Firms/LLPs
Companies
NGOs
Income Tax Notice
Income Tax Planning
Income Tax Litigation
Income Tax Computation
Charity
Section 8 Company
Recommended
Trust Registration
Society Registration
80G & 12A Registration
FCRA Registration
NITI Ayog Registration
CSR-1 Registration
CSR 2 Report
CSR Services
NGO Consultancy
NGO Handholding
Govt Grants Support
Partnership
Angel Investors
Venture Capitalists
Co-Working Spaces
Banks and NBFCs
Incubation Centres
Government Wings
Institutional Bodies
Software Companies
CA/CS/CMA/Lawyers
Press & Media Houses
Overseas Ventures
Other Startup Enablers
Contact Us
Home
Trademarks
A Battle Between the Coca-Cola Company v. Bisleri International Pvt. Ltd. For Trademark Infringement
A Battle Between the Coca-Cola Company v. Bisleri International Pvt. Ltd. For Trademark Infringement
Volume
1
Rate
1
Pitch
1
A Battle Between the Coca-Cola Company v. Bisleri International Pvt. Ltd. For Trademark Infringement. INTRODUCTION: The case of The Coca-Cola Company v. Bisleri International Pvt. Ltd. 2010 ILR DEL 2 278 revolves around a dispute over trademark infringement and passing off. The Coca-Cola Company, the largest brand of soft drinks operating in 200 countries, filed a suit against Bisleri International Pvt. Ltd., alleging that the defendant had infringed upon its registered trademark for the beverage "MAAZA." This article aims to provide a comprehensive analysis of the case, including the facts, issues, arguments, and the court's reasoning. FACTUAL BACKGROUND: The plaintiff, The Coca-Cola Company, claimed that it had acquired the rights to the trademark MAAZA through a Master Agreement with the defendant, Bisleri International Pvt. Ltd. However, the plaintiff alleged that the defendant had ignored the transfer of rights and continued to use the trademark without authorization. The plaintiff sought a permanent injunction and damages for trademark infringement and passing off. LEGAL ISSUES: Whether the court had jurisdiction to hear the case. Whether the defendant's use of the trademark MAAZA constituted infringement and passing off. Whether the plaintiff had established a prima facie case for the grant of an injunction. ARGUMENTS: The plaintiff argued that the defendant's use of the trademark MAAZA without authorization amounted to trademark infringement and passing off. The plaintiff also contended that the defendant's intention to use the mark within the jurisdiction of the court, as evidenced by a newspaper report, further supported the claim. The plaintiff relied on Section 134 of the Trademarks Act, 1999, to establish the court's jurisdiction. The defendant, on the other hand, argued that the court lacked jurisdiction to hear the case as the suit could have been filed in Mumbai, where the defendant had its registered office. The defendant also claimed that it did not intend to use the infringing trademark within the court's jurisdiction, as it recognized the plaintiff's exclusive rights over the mark. COURT'S REASONING: The court, in its reasoning, first addressed the issue of jurisdiction. It held that although the suit could have been filed in Mumbai, the plaintiff had alleged that its rights had been violated in Delhi. The court relied on Section 134 of the Trademarks Act, which allowed the plaintiff to file the suit in Delhi, as part of the cause of action had arisen there. Regarding the defendant's intention to use the mark, the court noted that the plaintiff had provided evidence of a newspaper report and a legal notice sent by the defendant, both indicating an intention to use the mark within the court's jurisdiction. The court held that at the prima facie stage, these averments supported the plaintiff's claim. The court also considered the defendant's argument regarding the invalidity of the plaintiff's claim. However, it held that the plaintiff had made out a prima facie case, and the defendant's objections could only be addressed after the recording of evidence. RELEVANT JUDGMENTS AND APPLICABILITY: Hindustan Pencils Private Limited v. India Stationery Products Co. (1989 SCC ONLINE DEL 34, Delhi High Court, 1989): This case establishes that the use of a mark can be considered by various means, including advertisement or intention to use the mark. It supports the court's reasoning in The Coca-Cola Company v. Bisleri International Pvt. Ltd. regarding the defendant's intention to use the infringing trademark. S.M Dyechem Ltd. v. Cadbury (India) Ltd. (2000 SCC 5 573, Supreme Court Of India, 2000): This case clarifies the rights conferred by registration of a trademark and the concept of infringement. It supports the plaintiff's argument that the defendant's use of a mark "deceptively similar" to the plaintiff's trademark constitutes infringement. CONCLUSION: The Coca-Cola Company v. Bisleri International Pvt. Ltd. case serves as a notable example of a trademark dispute in the beverage industry. The court's decision to protect Coca-Cola's trademark rights reinforces the importance of safeguarding brand identity and preventing consumer confusion. This case highlights the significance of conducting thorough trademark searches and ensuring the distinctiveness of marks to avoid potential legal disputes.? The ruling in The Coca-Cola Company v. Bisleri International Pvt. Ltd. case not only underscores the importance of protecting trademark rights but also sets a precedent for future trademark disputes in India's beverage industry. By affirming Coca-Cola's exclusive rights to the MAAZA trademark and restraining Bisleri from unauthorized use, the court sends a clear message about the enforcement of intellectual property rights. Furthermore, the case highlights the complexities surrounding jurisdictional issues in trademark disputes, particularly in cases involving multinational corporations operating across different regions. The court's interpretation of jurisdictional provisions under the Trademarks Act, 1999, provides guidance for similar disputes in determining the appropriate forum for legal proceedings. Moreover, the reliance on prior case law, such as Hindustan Pencils Private Limited v. India Stationery Products Co. and S.M Dyechem Ltd. v. Cadbury (India) Ltd., underscores the importance of precedent and established legal principles in resolving trademark infringement cases. This reliance on precedent ensures consistency and predictability in judicial decisions, thereby contributing to the stability of India's trademark law framework. Overall, The Coca-Cola Company v. Bisleri International Pvt. Ltd. case serves as a significant milestone in the jurisprudence surrounding trademark protection and enforcement in India, reaffirming the judiciary's commitment to upholding intellectual property rights and fostering a conducive environment for innovation and brand development in the beverage industry. Do you also think that your Registered mark is used by some other firm for their benefit? You can file a trademark infringement case today with the help of Compliance Calendar LLP. We will not only help you register your trademark but also protect your mark at all the stages of registration. For any further clarifications and suggestions, kindly connect on 9988424211 or mail at info@ccoffice.in.
Share this article:
Search more articles:
You may also like
The Ultimate Guide: How to Register Your Brand Name in India
How to Reply Trademark Objection in Examination Report under Section 9 and 11
Trademark Opposition Process in India
Trademark Infringement: Meaning, Types, Examples and How to Avoid TM Infringement
Trademark Renewal Process in India
Trademark Assignment Process: Learn How to Transfer Trademark Ownership
Stages of Trademark Registration Status - The Complete Manual
Trademark Status- Send to Vienna Codification
Trademark Status- Formalities Chk Pass
Trademark Status- Formalities Chk Failed
Trademark Application Status- Marked For Exam
Trademark Status- Examination Report Issued
Trademark Status- Objected
Trademark Status- Ready for Show Cause Hearing
Trademark Status- Advertised Before Accepted
Trademark Status- Accepted
Trademark Status- Accepted and Advertised
Trademark Status- Refused
Trademark Status- Abandoned
Trademark Status- Withdrawn
Trademark Status- Opposed
Trademark Status- Registered
Trademark Status- Removed
Absolute Grounds of 'Distinctive' and 'Distinguish' Character under Section 9(1) (a) of the Trademarks Act, 1999
Analysis of Trademark Genericide: Meaning, Effects and ways to Protect
An analysis on the proviso of Section 9 (1) (b) of the Trademark Act, 1999
What is Assignment and Transmission in Trademark?
How to protect your brand name by filing a Trademark Application
How Startups can protect their brand / Logo in India and Government supports
List of New Trademark Forms in India as per the Trademark Rules, 2017
What is Class 99 of Trademark Application- Is it a good or bad decision?
How to file Counter Statement for Trademark Opposition?
What are well known Trademarks and How to obtain it?
What is the difference between TM and ®
Protecting Your Brand: A Step-by-Step Guide to Trademark Registration
Trademark Law: Protecting your brand identity
Trademark Registration Online: Protect your Business IP
Reply to Trademark Objection on Relative Grounds of Refusal: Section 11 of Trademarks Act, 1999
Exploring Non-Conventional Trademarks Under the Trade Marks Act, 1999
YAHOO INC VS. AKASH ARORA AND ANR - Does Domain Name Constitute Trademark Infringement?
Concept and Protection of Trade Dress in Trade Mark
IPR for Social Media Influencers- Here's all you need to know
Damages for Trademark Violation - Puma Se vs. Ashok Kumar | Delhi HC
Delhi High Court on (Non) Functioning of the Trademark Registry Website/Portal
Safeguarding Food Trademarks: Domino’s vs. Dominick Pizza ruling on Deceptive Similarity
Have you claimed Depreciation on your Brand Name? Here’s a Landmark Ruling to watch out
The Case Against Meesho: Why E-Commerce Portals Must Ensure Complete Disclosure of Sellers Details
Special Drive Initiative to Expedite Pending Trademark Applications
Difference Between Trademark and Service Mark
Importance of Using Trademarks to Maintain Applicability in Indian Law
International Non-Proprietary Names (INN) and Trademark Laws in India
Process of Rectification of Trademark in India
Role of Trademark Attorneys in Trademark Registration
Why is Trademark Registration for Startups and Small Businesses Necessary?
Delhi High Court Rules in Favor of Google in Trademark Infringement Case
No Monopoly Can Be Claimed for Words of Common English Usage
Common Mistakes to Avoid When Choosing a Trademark for Your Brand
Brewed Trademark Infringement Case of Starbucks Vs Sardarbuksh
Exploring the Concept of 'Deceptive Similarity' in Trademarks Law
Why Filing of Evidence Before the Registrar of Trademarks is Crucial?
Rise of Domain Names as Trademarks in the Digital World
Concept of Passing Off in Indian Trade Mark Law
Evolution of Trademark Laws in India
Important of Power of Attorney (POA) in Trademark Filing
Trademark Issues in Co-branding and Collaborations
Trademark Enforcement Strategies for Online Marketplaces and Platforms
Trademarking Financial Services in the Fintech Industry
Interplay of Trademarks and Artificial Intelligence in the Modern Digitalized Era
Who can register a trademark in India?
Trademark Status- Protection Granted
Trademark Case Law: Sterling Agro Industries Limited v. ASR Trading Company
Registration of Color Trademark in India Under Trademarks Act, 1999
Trademarking Sustainable Tourism
Trademark Protection for NGOs / Non-Profit Organizations in India
Role of the USPTO in Trademark Registration
How to know the Trademark Status for Trademark Registration in India
Can a person trademark their own name in India?
Trademark Strategies for Startups - A Complete Guide
Supporting Documents Required for Attending Trademark Hearing in India
How to fight Trademark Infringement bonafide if your mark is different?
When to file for Trademark Abandoned Status as an Applicant?
Trademark Registration Online: The Complete Process and Cost
Extent of exclusivity granted over the shape of a product by trademark registration in India
Process of Trademark Withdrawal in India
Should Trademark Logo (Device) be filed in colour or black and white (grey)?
Bearing the Burden of Common Use in Trademark Ownership
Start Your Business
Private Limited Registration
Public Company Registration
OPC Pvt Ltd Registration
LLP Firm Registration
Section 8 Company Registration
Nidhi Company Registration
Insurance Company Registration
NBFC Company Registration
Producer Company Registration
Foreign Subsidiary Registration
Foreign Branch Office
Foreign Liaison Office
Foreign Project Office
Overseas Company Registration
Proprietorship Firm Registration
Partnership Firm Registration
Grow Your Business
GST Registration
MSME Registration(UDYAM)
Shop & Establishment Registration
Startup India Registration
ESI/PF Registration
IEC Code (Import Export)
Startup Consultation
Appoint Virtual CFO
Angel Funding/ VCs
Virtual Office Service
Due Diligence of Company
Business Development
Protect Your Business
Trademark Registration
Trademark Objection
Trademark Hearing
Trademark Opposition
Trademark Infringement
Trademark Renewal
Trademark Assignment
Trademark Withdrawal
Trademark Monitoring
Logo Design Service
Copyright Registration
Patent Registration
Exit Your Business
Close Company
Fast Track
Close LLP
Close Firm
GST Cancellation
Change Services
Change Company Name
Change LLP Name
Change Company Object
Change LLP Object
Increase Authorised Capital
Increase Paid-up Capital
Increase LLP Capital
Transfer of Shares
Alteration in MoA & AoA
Resignation of Auditor
Appointment of Director
Resignation of Director
Change in Designation of Director
Shifting Registered Office of Company
Shifting Registered Office of LLP
Dormant Status of Company
Mandatory Compliances
Appoinment of Auditor
Annual Filings of Company
Annual Filings of LLP
Annual DIN/DPIN KYC
Annual Return of Deposits
Half Yearly MSME Return
Statutory Registers & Minutes
XBRL Filing of Companies
eStamping of Share Certificates
Dematerialisation of Shares
RBI FEMA Compliance
GST Returns Filing
ESI-EPF Returns Filing
TDS Returns Filing
Change in Structure
Proprietorship to OPC
OPC to Private Limited
Private Limited to OPC
LLP to Private Limited
Private Limited to LLP
Partnership Firm to LLP
Private Limited to Public Company
Public Company to Private Limited
Trust/Society to Section 8 Company
Existing Company to Section 8
Existing Section 8 to Company
Services
Accounting & Book Keeping
GST Compliance
Valuation Services
Corporate Litigation
Company Law Advisory
Services For Banks
Drafting & Vetting Services
Startups Funding
Business Loans
Get in Touch
NBFC
NBFC Company Registration
NBFC Micro-Finance Registration
NBFC P2P Lending Registration
NBFC Core Investment Company
NBFC ROC Compliance
NBFC RBI Compliance
NBFC License Restoration
NBFC Business Plan
NBFC Acquisition
NBFC Consultancy
NBFC Compliance Calendar
NBFC Independent Director
ISO
ISO 9001:2015
ISO 14001:2015
ISO 13485:2016
OHSAS 18001:2007
HACCP Certification
CE Marking
GMP Certification
CMMI Level 3 Certification
ISO 22000:2005
ISO 27001:2013
FSSAI
FSSAI Registration
FSSAI State License
FSSAI Central License
FSSAI Registration Renewal
FSSAI License Renewal
FSSAI Returns Filing
FSSAI Compliances
FSSAI Consultancy
ITR
Salaried Person
Firms/LLPs
Companies
NGOs
Income Tax Notice
Income Tax Planning
Income Tax Litigation
Charity
Section 8 Company
Trust Registration
Society Registration
80G & 12A Registration
FCRA Registration
NITI Ayog Registration
CSR-1 Registration
CSR 2 Report
CSR Services
NGO Consultancy
NGO Handholding
Govt Grants Support
Partnership
Angel Investors
Venture Capitalists
Co-Working Spaces
Banks and NBFCs
Incubation Centres
Government Wings
Institutional Bodies
Software Companies
CA/CS/CMA/Lawyers
Press & Media Houses
Overseas Ventures
Other Startup Enablers
Contact Us